The workload has gotten overwhelming, and the bottom line finally justifies hiring someone new. You’re overjoyed, but in your excitement, don’t overlook these common pitfalls. You're choosing the person you'll work with regularly, trust with customers, and count on to help your business grow. Hiring mistakes often happen when business owners rush, don’t take time to figure out what they need, or simply want to fill the position so they can move on to everything else.
The process can be especially awkward for entrepreneurs and small teams working remotely or in a hybrid arrangement. You may be interviewing candidates by Zoom, meeting at coffee shops, or squeezing conversations between client appointments. Sometimes it helps to have a place where you can close the door and give the conversation your full attention. Burbity Workspaces offers meeting rooms in Spokane Valley and Liberty Lake for exactly that.
Whether you're making your first hire or adding to an established team, keep these common mistakes in mind.
1. Hiring Because You're Desperate for Help
You've been working evenings and weekends for months. Your inbox is overflowing, customers are waiting, and you're beginning to wonder whether you'll ever take a real vacation again. At this point, almost anyone who can take a few things off your plate sounds like a blessing.
Don't underestimate the need for help. Every additional week without someone in the role means more work for you or the rest of your team, and burnout is looming. But that pressure can make a reasonably qualified candidate look better than they might have under different circumstances. You overlook a gap in experience or convince yourself that something you noticed during the interview probably won't matter.
Before posting the job, take time to figure out which responsibilities you most urgently need to hand over. You may discover that the position you originally had in mind isn't what your business needs now. Make sure your first hires are the right hires.
2. Writing a Job Description That Doesn't Reflect the Job
In a small business, the person hired to answer phones may also end up coordinating events, ordering supplies, and helping customers when things get busy. Job responsibilities tend to evolve as the business grows, and employees often take on work that doesn't fit neatly into a traditional job title.
That's worth explaining to applicants. A description filled with expressions like "dynamic self-starter" and "excellent multitasking skills" tells someone very little about how they'll spend their days. Think about the tasks that need to get done, the people they’ll work with, and the decisions they'll be expected to make on their own.
If the job sometimes involves evening events, difficult customer conversations, or pitching in wherever help is needed, include those details. You want applicants to recognize themselves in the work you're describing.
3. Looking for Someone Just Like You
Have you ever finished an interview thinking, "I could really see myself working with that person"? Maybe you discovered a shared interest, laughed at the same things, or found that the conversation moved easily.
Those are pleasant experiences, but they don't necessarily tell you whether someone can do the job. We tend to favor people who approach problems the way we do, even when our businesses would benefit from someone with a different perspective.
Consider an entrepreneur who loves developing new ideas but struggles to keep projects organized. Hiring another creative, big-picture thinker might lead to lively brainstorming, but would that be the most beneficial hire? Someone who enjoys building systems, tracking details, and keeping everyone on schedule could be a much more useful addition.
4. Relying Too Much on First Impressions
Some people are terrific at interviews. They speak confidently, have an interesting story for every question, and seem completely at ease talking with someone they've just met. Others are nervous or need a little time to collect their thoughts. It's easy to mistake a good interview for evidence that someone will do well in the job.
One way to keep first impressions from carrying too much weight is to ask candidates the same core questions. You'll have a better basis for comparison, particularly if those questions relate to situations they're likely to encounter at work.
For example, instead of asking whether someone is good with difficult customers, ask them to describe an actual disagreement or complaint they've handled. What was the situation? What did they do? How did it turn out? Their answer may tell you more than a general description of their customer service skills.
5. Skipping the Practical Skills Test
A candidate's resume says they're proficient using spreadsheets. Great. But what does proficient mean? Can they build a useful report, or do they know how to enter numbers into cells?
Depending on the position, it may be worth including a short exercise that resembles the work they'll be doing. A marketing applicant could review a sample social media post and suggest improvements. An administrative candidate might organize a mock schedule. Someone applying for a customer service position could walk you through how they'd respond to a common customer problem.
There's no need to turn the interview into an afternoon of unpaid work. Keep the exercise brief, relevant, and consistent across applicants. You're looking for a glimpse of how someone thinks and works, which is hard to judge from a resume alone.
Looking for a Professional Workspace For Your Small Business?
Burbity Workspaces has office spaces and meeting rooms available!
6. Forgetting to Discuss Remote and Hybrid Expectations
A candidate may tell you they're comfortable working remotely, and you move on to the next question. Pause. Remote and hybrid work definitions and expectations deserve more attention.
You don’t want to find out after you’ve hired someone that your expectations differ considerably. Say, you assumed they'd be available during regular business hours and attend the occasional in-person meeting. They assumed something much more loosely structured, with communication happening primarily through email or text messaging. Neither arrangement is necessarily unreasonable, but you should have this conversation before someone accepts the position.
Talk about how your team communicates, when employees need to be available, and how often people are expected to meet in person. Ask candidates about their previous experiences working independently and how they keep projects moving when coworkers aren't nearby. For hybrid teams, these everyday habits can significantly affect how smoothly people work together.
7. Talking More Than You Listen
Business owners are understandably enthusiastic about their companies. You've worked hard to build something, and you want candidates to recognize the opportunity. Without intending to, you can find you’ve spent most of the interview explaining your business, describing plans, and telling stories about how everything got started. The candidate has barely said a word.
Sharing your enthusiasm has value, especially with someone who may join the team. But try to leave enough room for an authentic conversation. Ask follow-up questions when something interests you, and resist the urge to fill each quiet moment.
Pay attention to the questions candidates ask, too. Someone who wants to know how decisions are made, what challenges the team is facing, or how success will be measured may be giving you useful insight into what matters to them.
8. Neglecting Reference Checks
When you've met someone you really like, checking references can feel like an unnecessary formality. You've already decided they're a great fit, and you're anxious to get them started.
Still, it's worth making a few calls. A former supervisor or colleague may be able to tell you about responsibilities the candidate handled that didn't come up during the interview. You might learn how they responded when a project went off track or what kind of management helped them do their best work.
Reference conversations are most useful when you have specific questions related to the position. Get the candidate's permission, follow applicable hiring laws, and use what you learn alongside the other information you've gathered. One person's experience won't tell you everything, but it may give you a better sense of what it would be like to work with the candidate.
9. Making the Hiring Process Unnecessarily Complicated
Have you ever applied for something online, answered a long list of questions, uploaded your resume, and then been asked to enter everything from that same resume manually? It's frustrating, especially when you never hear anything back.
Employers sometimes create similar frustrations without realizing it. An applicant comes in for an interview, then another, and then a third conversation with someone who asks many of the same questions. Weeks pass without an update, and the candidate has no idea whether the company is still interested.
Small businesses don't necessarily have dedicated HR staff to manage every detail. That's understandable. But a little organization goes a long way. Decide who needs to participate in interviews, explain the process to applicants, and try to keep them informed when timelines change.
Remember, candidates learn about your business throughout the hiring process. The way you communicate and respect their time may influence whether they ultimately want to work for you. Make sure you don’t lose the opportunity to hire the best employee for the job.
10. Assuming the Work Is Done Once Someone Accepts
After weeks of reviewing applications and conducting interviews, you've finally found the right person. They accept your offer, and you can get back to everything else demanding your attention. Then Monday morning arrives, and your new employee is sitting at a desk without a working computer, waiting for someone to explain what they're supposed to do.
Most small business owners don't intend to neglect onboarding. They're simply busy, and the people who know how everything works are usually the same people keeping the business running.
Think through your new employee’s first week before they arrive. Make sure they have access to the tools they need, introduce them to coworkers, and identify a few manageable priorities. For remote and hybrid teams, scheduled check-ins are particularly helpful because they can't always turn to the person at the next desk when a question comes up. It may take a little extra time upfront, but those first conversations can prevent a lot of confusion later.
Building a Team That Works Well Together
One interesting thing about running a small business is how much it changes when you bring in another person. A team of three operates differently from a team of two. Someone new brings their own habits, ideas, strengths, and expectations, and everyone has to adjust.
You won't get every hiring decision right, and even a carefully chosen employee will need time to settle in. But being clear about what you need and giving candidates a realistic picture of the job can help you avoid common hiring mistakes.
As your team grows, you may also find that your workspace needs to change. Burbity Workspaces offers private offices and flexible workspaces for Spokane-area entrepreneurs and businesses that need room to work, meet, and collaborate. Whether your employees come together every day or just a few times a week, having a comfortable place to gather can make those working relationships easier to build.



